Magnetic Island North Queensland
  Phone 0427 398 838 Sunday 18th o March 2018 on Magnetic Island  
A young koala's beach adventure

December 11th 2008
"We don't need to wait to make a better Island"

The transport study meeting The Nelly to Arcadia walkway, parking at Nelly Bay harbour, bus sizes and the possible lowering of the speed limit were the main discussion points of a meeting held last week between representatives of various Magnetic Island transport businesses, community organisations and the Deputy Mayor David Crisafulli.

The meeting came after the release of the Magnetic Island Land Transport Study - intended to improve and develop transport options over the next 20 years.

The study was conducted by the previous council in 2006, but not presented to the public until now. Yesterday we reproduced a TCC newsletter based on the community consultation and today we report some of the viewpoints held by those who attended the meeting - namely representatives of Island organisations and individuals who'd made submissions to the study.

Deputy Mayor, David Crisafulli, earlier described the report as, "warts and all" and, with findings such as, "no resident had a good word to say about the Nelly Bay terminal," one could hardly disagree.

Clearly there is much to the report and it was pointed out that the larger and longer term proposals will need to be incorporated into the Local Area Plan which will inform the next City Plan - two or more years away.

With a view to what is possible David Crisafulli told Magnetic Times, "that while there is grant money involved with a number of proposals there are things we can do to get the ball rolling."

On the "number one issue," the Nelly to Arcadia walkway, he said, "It gives us a great opportunity to go to government to say, 'Here you have a community behind a cause government can hang their hat on." Thinking in terms of an upcoming Queensland election and the possible leverage which may be possible to achieve, he added, " The Island speaking as one lends a lot of weight to a cause."

The walkway proposal, estimated at over $4M, has loomed large for many years and it is worth noting that Magnetic Island Nature Care (MINCA) representative, Charlie McColl, added another perspective. Mindful that engineering requirements may well result in an unattractive structure, he suggested that the project be opened to a wider range of options including a suspended structure which sat away from the cliff face. Richard Poutney from Go-Electric and Magnetic Island Bike Hire described this as an, "excellent submission".

On a possible change of the speed limit to 50kph for all Island roads, Cr Crisafulli said there was a willingness (by participants) to go back to the groups they represented and talk about the possibility of a reducing the speed limit to 50kph, and added, rather refreshingly, that, "It's not for a mainlander to tell Islanders what to do," and advised that "the community needs to champion the cause".

Cr Crisafulli said, however, that reducing the speed limit across the Island to 50kph would, "promote the Island's laid-back life style," and that this was an issue that didn't need to wait, like the other longer-term plans for inclusion into the Local Area Plan, which would eventually become part of the City Plan. "My door is open for representations. We don't need to wait to make a better Island." he said.

The lower speed limit is something Magnetic Times has called for already - more than anything because it would help reduce the Island's shocking amounts of road-kill and, with our online poll presently running at 67% in favour of the reduction (see front page, lower right-side column, to vote), there is definitely strong support.

But this issue is more complicated when we try to navigate a good public transport outcome as well. Jan Pranskunus, Manager of the MI Bus Service told Magnetic Times that a slowing of the speed limit would make it very hard for the present number of buses to deliver passengers within the ferry turn-around times. The point is critical to the discussion as the great bone of contention - the lack of parking space at Nelly Bay Terminal - can be very well addressed by more people catching buses.

With MIBS, now under the new management of Transit Australia there is an expectation in some quarters that a number of their smaller buses, as seen in Townsville, may be redeployed to Magnetic. With smaller buses, which would be welcomed on the Island's narrow roads, it is likely that the company would require more services and the need to pay more drivers. And to make the bus service more attractive to a greater number of commuters some have suggested a main arterial express bus service combined with a slower service that collects less agile passengers from closer to their homes. This would again require more drivers.

As for the size of the carpark, Charlie McColl, questioned why there should be extra car parking created when greater use of public transport is required.

This subject also feeds into the wider issue of growth on Magnetic Island. The survey found 77% of respondents to consider it a problem.

MI Community Development Association representative, Peter le Grand saw need for , "policy to determine the limits to growth coupled to complementary policy to address attitudinal change and habit adjustment."

Cr Crisafulli said that parking is an issue that we need to address with all means - from other transport options to freeing up existing car spaces. "Some cars are left for weeks" he said but wouldn't commit to parking meters being installed to prevent this. "I cant say yes or no. We'd need to see strong support."

Bruce Williams is the transport spokesperson for Magnetic Island Residents and Ratepayers Association and, although personally in favour of seeing the speed limit lowered, as MIRRA representative, maintains the present MIRRA position that the speed limit remain at 60kph, saying, "I have learned to respect the anti-case, as expressed by a number of MIRRA members and supporters.

Bruce Williams wrote to Magnetic Times, "Magnetic Islanders who operate businesses and services, including a number of Taxi Drivers have vigorously promoted the keeping of the 60 km/hr, largely because these businesses are confronted by urgencies and emergencies which may not be experienced by the community as a whole. Failure of electrical appliances or supply and the likelihood of missed crucial airflights, appointments or opportunities are just some of the pressing issues which confront business and business operators.

"I respect such realities but have no solutions to them at this stage.

Interestingly, Mr Bill Flavel, who operates the Magnetic Island Taxis was, according to others at the meeting, in support of the lowered speed limit. Magnetic Times has, as yet, been unable to interview Mr Flaven directly.

Bruce Williams, who is also a taxi driver, went on to say, "However I also personally respect and support the lower speed-limit as a "sacrifice" necessary to maintain and to promote an "Island Ambience" which can be seen to be threatened. The accelerated roadkill and the role of rush and haste seems to me to represent a threat to those very qualities of Magnetic Island life which entice both visitors and migrants to these shores. Although it may defy definition, we would all recognise when it has gone. This ambience must be maintained at all costs. Even if the personal or fiscal cost might seem to be excessive, we must keep Magnetic an Island. At the conclusion of the latest MIRRA Survey, I can reveal that many members of the Magnetic Island Ratepayers and Residents Association Ltd are strongly in favour of the change to 50 km/hr."

Bruce Williams is, it seems, very committed to a solution and has since told Magnetic Times, "In order that the MI community might make informed judgments about this (lower speed limit) and other "ambience-related" issues, it is likely that a CBSM (Community-Based Social Marketing) project will be conducted in the New Year.

"I already have MIRRA approval to conduct a CBSM project on the topic of "Road Kill" which, if it were to be linked with "Lowered Speed Limits" seems to be subservient to a larger topic of "Appropriate Road Use on Magnetic Island". I will put that to MIRRA at the February meeting.

His approach is clearly constructive. He adds, " We probably will need to find a creative solution which is unique to Magnetic Island. So what? We can do it if we cooperate."

To add your comment,
or read those of others, see below

"We don't need to wait to make a better Island"
December 11th 2008
why should the happy motorist get priority of the roadway from nelly bay to arcadia, we could place trafic lights ether end and use half the roadway for bikes and walkers, that is if there is that much support, we could easyly trial it for minimal cost using those portable lights and deviding the road with temporary fencing, maybe to coincide with a special event where there would be plenty of people taking advantage of it.
just an idea on how to save 4 mill and discorage use of the car.
teresa e j doughty
December 11th 2008
as a recent tourist/visitor to Magnetic Island, i heartily agree with the need to preserve the Island`s `ambience`. This is a unique beautiful and natural place, and it is to Australia`s credit that the islanders appreciate how precious it is to residents, tourists, and wildlife alike.
Chris C
December 12th 2008
There's an argument for keeping a 60k speed limit ????
John Becker
December 12th 2008

The matter of emergencies and urgency; what utter rubbish. Police, ambulance and fire brigaade have sirens and can exceed the speed limit, as can a citizen, who if pulled over and supplies a proper explanation, would get a police escort.
Missing a ferry or running late is NOT an emergency. Bad planning, disorganization and panic is not emergency making and is not an excuse. Try for an earlier ferry than the one you want, and if you miss it, so what? Better to be early and bored (though a good book can remedy that) than being in a panic with the associated adrenalin rush, bad temper, raised blood pressure and the potential for an asthma, stroke or heart attack.
December 12th 2008
Now that Council has acknowledged how unpopular Nelly Bay Harbour is with islanders, I suppose it would be asking too much to have TCC demolish it all and cart it away? On a more realistic note, its a pleasure and a relief to see Council listening (or appearing to listen) to those whose lives are so affected by their decisions. Although the proof is in the pudding, this seems like a good start.

Peter le Grand
December 12th 2008
Let us open this discussion a tadge wider.
I live in the 'short' end of Swensen St - the No Through Road bit.
There have been 5 Rock Wallaby 'kills' these past 4 days.
Now that begs some questions.
There are 7 permanent residences - 5 with dogs - and I would venture that those permanent residences are most conscious of the fact of there being many Rock Wallabies in this sector.
That leaves the either the (8th) newly built residence (presumed a holiday let as it has been 'occupied' this week)) or transient tourists or visitors to the 7 residences.
I certainly have had no 'visitors' - I cannot vouch for the remaining 6.
As I note, it begs questions.
And the 'kills were not caused by dogs.
At a crude guess I would initially suspect that some visiting the island, seduced by the 'laid back' tourist promo's for the island, have left (and I am being polite) their civic conventions behind.
Alternatively, the mindset and behaviour of some locals must be seriously in question.
John Becker is correct - learn to get a little bored or alternatively learn to read but extend this beyond connecting with a ferry and make it part of your island traverse travel per se.
Who was it that said ...'the faster you go the narrower your focus'...?

Steve Ashton
December 18th 2008
The point raised about the design of any walkway from Nelly Bay to Arcadia is really important. There should be a proper design exercise lead by an architect and a landscape archietct with clever engineering advice before any decisions are made on this. A solely engineering driven solution is not the right way to address this problem - it is in a highly visible and sensitive part of the island. It need not cost more - it just need some hard and creative thinking.

What do you think? Send us your comments.

Readers comments
FROM cp_articles
[ read more ]
The poll
Should Magnetic Island commission a sculpture to celebrate the achievements of Julian Assange?
98%       2%
Great idea No thanks

Cypress created this page in 0.07 seconds